I sit slightly reclined in the new chair, in the new meeting room, in the new headquarters. Light filters in through the slats of the self-adjusting blinds, breaking into thin streaks that draw soft, abstract geometries on the walls. And yet, in some way, I miss my old office, in the old house. Dark and mysterious, it was the place where, almost guiltily, I would light a cigar just to watch the absurd dance of the smoke in the room and the way it played with the dim light. Even now, I can still see the mixture of dust and smoke suspended in that intangible space, belonging neither to light nor to darkness, and yet holding both at once.
I sit there, as I was saying, thinking about the last meeting. It was not the issue itself, the one we had all been left unclear about, that truly mattered, but rather how I was going to respond to it. It was already evident to me, even during the meeting, that my colleague’s proposal was flawed. The passivity of some and the support of others were equally irrelevant. What mattered was how I would react. The stakes were neither high nor low, but just right—optimal—for throwing you into a genuine dilemma.
I often find myself in situations where the way I respond matters more than the technical correctness of the intervention itself. I have always felt that such moments are decisive, both for the kind of leadership you practice and for the kind of organization you choose to cultivate. More often than not, instinct pushes you naturally into the position from which, drawing on experience and authority, you point out the “right” solution with ease and confidence.
It is worth pausing for a moment on this notion of the “right solution.” Unfortunately, situations in which reality offers a single, clear, and indisputable option are rare. In practice, there is usually a range of acceptable solutions, each accompanied—like a symbiotic parasite—by its own advantages and disadvantages. Inevitably, purely subjective elements enter the picture as well: those that shape how we measure the results of a decision’s implementation and, in particular, how we weigh advantages against disadvantages.
Without complicating the discussion unnecessarily, I return to the dilemma of the right decision as I perceive it. On the one hand, it is assumed that the person at the head of an organization possesses superior competence and can identify optimal solutions across a broad spectrum of problems. On the other hand, a mature organization, built on a healthy culture, should be capable of making decisions through its members, without relying excessively on the intervention of top leaders—or even the one at the very top.
So we return to the new conference room. A colleague, responsible for a specific issue, was proposing a solution that seemed clearly wrong to me. Even after all the reflections above, the stakes still felt moderate, and the tolerance for the risk of a wrong decision reasonably high. I knew that a direct intervention—a “no, we’ll do it this way,” spoken after I had deliberately encouraged the group to assume responsibility for a decision—would have damaged the culture I had worked so hard to nurture: a culture in which people are free to decide and responsible for facing the consequences of their decisions. As an aside, I am the kind of CEO whose phone does not ring incessantly, who takes vacations undisturbed, and who is sometimes even frustrated by not being “looped in” on many initiatives.
It seems important to me, especially in moments like these, where there is room for trial and error, for practice and experimentation, to pause for a moment and think carefully about the kind of organization you want to grow—and the culture you want to sustain. It matters whether you want an organization in which you always have the final word and reap the credit and recognition, at the risk of absolute dependence, accumulated personal errors, lack of initiative, and creativity constrained by your own imagination; or whether you prefer to encourage constructive conflict between ideas and options, even at the cost of losing some control over the outcome. Perhaps you want to watch, with genuine delight, how responsible interaction among its members leads to development independent of your direct action.
Perhaps you choose to walk alongside the child learning to ride a bicycle, following the apparently chaotic balancing act, offering essential support while allowing the wobble, and sharing in the joy of the triumphant shout when balance is finally found—by one of them, or by many.
Every effort against entropy comes with a cost, and I was quietly measuring the cost of my own non-intervention—a cost that would almost certainly turn into a wrong decision. Because yes, this is ultimately about weighing the cost of allowing a mistake to manifest against the cost borne by organizational culture. The latter translates into missed lessons, into the frustration that “the boss wants it his way,” into the absence of awareness that a mistake was even made—since, more often than not, only its full manifestation makes it visible.
The leader lives—dare I say it—surrounded by more dilemmas than a reasonable average, and one of the most difficult among them is exercising the right attitude in situations like the one described above. When is it right to allow a wrong decision to unfold, giving the organization the chance to learn, to assume responsibility, and to strengthen decision-making at other levels? And when is it necessary to intervene, to correct and prevent the waste of resources?
I stood up and slowly crossed the space toward the door. I had been doing this for a long time—perhaps for too long. I could sense the restless thoughts of those aware of the mistake, see the confident smiles of those supporting it, and turn over in my mind the costs that were about to emerge. No, it is neither easy nor meant for everyone to lead. We often forget that leadership is an extraordinarily complex process and one that is essential to the progress of humanity. We confuse degrees with leadership competence, attitude with value, time spent in a role with genuine experience.
We are entering a new year, and I do not wish to close without wishing all those who follow this series of articles a wonderful year—one that brings meaning to your efforts and pleasure to your time away from work.
Happy New Year.