Key Points
- The prosumer phenomenon has been politically over-encouraged, even though it has reached a level where it needs to be limited, as it creates technical imbalances and hidden costs for the rest of the consumers. The excessive benefits for 250,000 prosumers are indirectly paid for by the other 9 million consumers.
- The lack of investments in storage systems causes prosumers to feed electricity into the grid erratically, affecting the stability and economic fairness of the energy system, even though their contributions can sometimes be beneficial. Romania urgently needs support programs for prosumer storage.
- Electricity prices in Romania are too high relative to the country’s resources and potential, due to three decades of underinvestment in new capacity. While not the highest in Europe, prices are above the European average. Industry is affected.
- There are no real short-term solutions to reduce electricity prices, but ongoing investments are expected to lead, within 2–3 years, to significant reductions, bringing prices below the European average.
- A total blackout is unlikely; the real risks stem from technical errors or human factors, and a blackout would require multiple problems to occur simultaneously. A blackout cannot happen solely due to a production deficit, because consumption would then be intentionally curtailed.
- Romania and the European Union need to collaborate more closely on regional energy security and on supporting Ukraine, which is a European—not just a regional—issue.
- Peace talks in Ukraine will inevitably have a strong energy component, and Russian gas should not be allowed to flow to Europe again after any peace settlement with Russia.
Full Interview:
Reporter: There is a change in the law regarding prosumers. There are two positive things for them: 1. Payment in the following month and 2. Compensation against other bills, possibly gas if they are with the same provider. Is this again a form of “incentivizing” them as they multiply? Is it good or bad?
Corneliu Bodea: It is not good. Not because some of these measures wouldn’t have been normal or natural, but because it represents a new encouragement while the prosumer phenomenon is clearly already over-encouraged.
I would start by saying that prosumers are consumers who have the means and invest in electricity generation systems primarily for their own consumption. The idea behind prosumers is to allow and encourage them to produce electricity to cover their own use. Of course, without storage systems, they might produce at times when they don’t consume, and in that case exchanging with the grid could be considered intelligent—provided the installations they set up don’t exceed their own consumption.
In Romania, this phenomenon has again been “interpreted the Romanian way” and, I believe, used for electoral purposes. I am very surprised to see politicians, some whom I admire, praising these additional incentives for prosumers, while knowing that the phenomenon in Romania has already exceeded normal levels.
We have: 1. Production installations that far exceed the contracted consumption; 2. Installations without storage and without the prospect or incentive to install it, because the current mechanism encourages feeding electricity into the grid without sufficiently incentivizing storage. It’s too permissive: they are paid the next month, they can offset with other locations or energy forms. Taken together—even if some aspects alone might seem reasonable—they create a phenomenon that is both technically dangerous and economically unfair.
These practices impose costs: they generate electricity when its market price should be much lower than what they are paid, and they use the grid without covering any costs themselves.
Reporter: They argue the grid charges them extra because, when they take back electricity, they shouldn’t pay, for instance, a transport fee.
Corneliu Bodea: They do use the grid, both when injecting and when drawing from it. These costs are socialized—borne by those without generation systems—which is unfair. Even though 250,000 consumers benefit, the remaining 9 million bear the costs of these excessive incentives.
In my opinion, prosumers are beneficial as long as they are properly regulated and primarily use the electricity they produce for themselves, producing at most the same amount they consume. Ideally, this would have been paired with storage. State funding for prosumers to install solar panels should also have supported storage programs, benefiting both prosumers and the grid.
Reporter: Regarding the grid, conflicts have arisen over operators checking protections and inverters. Prosumers claimed violations of rights, alleging that the aim is either to tax them or stop production. How should the system function to work for both prosumers and the grid?
Corneliu Bodea: Operators must have access to and control over inverters. With over 250,000 locations, costs are significant—millions of euros for control systems. These costs are socialized again, affecting those without production systems. Some prosumers deliver energy without contracts, whenever they wish, sometimes destabilizing the grid.
Reporter: So it affects everyone else.
Corneliu Bodea: Correct. In some areas, voltages can reach 270V due to overproduction, blocking others. Transformer fluctuations create major problems. This shows a lack of logic: legislation was poorly designed, with populist intentions. It is hard to reverse these advantages once given.
Reporter: Should the expansion stop? There are 3 GW now.
Corneliu Bodea: During discussions about the “sun tax,” politicians could have applied it intelligently, taxing the income from prosumer production rather than the sun itself. Populism prevented this. Gradually discouraging excessive production would have normalized the system.
Reporter: In terms of capacity, 3 GW with state funds is unprecedented.
Corneliu Bodea: Yes, it is the largest “investor” in energy infrastructure—spread across over 250,000 people. This brings both positive and negative outcomes; I believe negatives outweigh positives because it’s out of control. Corrective measures in the future will cause tension.
Reporter: Let’s talk prices. Romania’s electricity prices are said to be the highest.
Corneliu Bodea: Prices are higher than they should be given our resources and potential—not the highest in Europe, but well above the average. Industry competitiveness suffers. The government should create a framework to encourage investment in electricity generation to reduce prices. Recent investments in renewables (solar, wind) will take 2–3 years to bear fruit, adding thousands of MW. Flexible generation and storage systems are needed to manage production intermittency. Romania has gas, hydro, wind, and solar potential—it could achieve prices below the EU average.
Reporter: Short-term measures won’t reduce prices, right?
Corneliu Bodea: Correct. No real short-term solution exists. Current measures mainly increase market discipline, not directly reduce prices. However, investments underway will likely lower prices significantly in 2–3 years, potentially below the EU average.
Reporter: And blackouts?
Corneliu Bodea: True blackouts are unlikely due to capacity shortages. Controlled disconnections manage temporary deficits. Blackouts would require multiple simultaneous failures—technical faults or human error. Romania’s grid is interconnected and resilient.
Reporter: How about Ukraine?
Corneliu Bodea: European cooperation is essential for regional energy security and support for Ukraine. Projects like submarine cables and interconnections should be pursued urgently. Ukraine’s nuclear capacity is critical, and energy planning must integrate it into European mechanisms while avoiding renewed dependence on Russian gas.
Corneliu Bodea is president of the Romanian Energy Center (CRE), a professional non-governmental, non-profit organization representing public and private energy sector companies in Romania and Brussels since 2011. He also represents Romania in Eurelectric and founded Adrem, a company specializing in energy infrastructure and industrial consumer solutions with over 1,000 employees nationwide.
Source: e-nergia.ro