Eagerly awaited by the politic and economic environment of the EU, the report drawn by the former head of the European Central Bank, Mario Draghi, addresses the uncomfortable issue of economic competitiveness in Europe. On this complex topic, the report repeatedly refers to various aspects of a major economic impact on energy transition. In this article I am going to study those very aspects, and try to decipher a message that should reach both the competent Romanian authorities and the entire private economic environment, which is going to be affected by the changes foreseen by the report.
EU’s economic competitiveness has lately become a topic of constant criticism of the policies of the European Commission (CE), as its power decreases as compared to its main global competitors, such as China and the USA. This decrease goes along a significant increase of the reliance on exterior imports, especially China. The war of the taxes imposed on electric vehicles clearly illustrates this issue, whether these imports are raw materials or finite products. In order to combat this trend, people in the European industry got together in February in Antwerp to issue a common statement requiring the European Commission to devise an industrial pact that is similar to Green Deal, with the precise objective of bringing competitiveness back among the most important topics of the policy of the new commission.
Centred around the fight against climate change and reducing emissions, EU’s policy is seen today as the main factor having led to an increase of energy prices and, thus, to the reduction of the competitiveness of industrial production and to an increase of dependence, mostly on China.
Now, if I may draw a comparison with the so-called ‘’morality issue”, I would dare say that this is the most difficult issue faced by today’s economy. On one hand, it goes without saying that the fight against climate change, seen by the most renowned scientists as the main risk for our species, must go on. On the other hand, two significant questions should be asked: how relevant is the decrease of emissions by the EU within the global economy, and how could the European Union support both the objectives of this combat, and the economic competitiveness in relation with other countries which implement policies which clearly favour their own economies?
While not pretending to provide a magical solution, the Draghi report identifies a series of alternatives, policies and steps which must urgently be taken into consideration by the new Commission. More specifically, five main obstacles have been identified which hinder economic growth, all from the energy field, namely:
- The market regulations which prevent the industry from benefitting from the advantages of energy transition and renewable energy;
- The high volatility of energy prices, especially on the spot markets;
- The long period of time needed to get the necessary approvals for developing energy projects and tax differences between the member states;
- The lack of a common industrial strategy within the EU;
- The extended energy imports of the EU.
As for the objectives that have been identified, the report suggests a common plan within the EU aiming towards an increased competitiveness and decarbonisation, along with increased security and less energy dependence.
Some of the indicated solutions consist of identifying and signing strategic partnerships for energy imports (with the USA, for instance) and introducing common financial mechanisms, such as uniform taxation and mobilised private capital. It is also suggested to support long-term contracts between producers and consumers (PPAs), new regulations at the level of energy trading and revisited mechanisms of price formation. At the level of infrastructure, the report suggests increasing the interconnection of energy systems, reducing the amount of time needed to have projects approved, investing in storage, as well as introducing request flexibility mechanisms. Moreover, it is suggested developing carbon capture, storage and use technologies, developing green hydrogen solutions, and, of course, cutting edge nuclear technologies, in order to keep supporting energy transition.
The harmonisation of the measures meant to support energy consumers at the level of the EU, the strengthening of the Energy Union of EU, the designation of a EU coordinating body to supervise and coordinate market regulations, and the improvement of provisions and data access within the energy industry constitute the main factors in the section of the report related to governance and the energy market.
In short, this would be an extremely brief record of the main directions identified by Mario Draghi in his report, directly related to the issue of the EU energy industry.
While not claiming to support the directions in the report 100%, I can say that I agree with both the identified issues and the suggested solutions. But what is more relevant than my own opinion is the way Romania and the competent energy authorities interpret this report, as well as the measures which are likely to be implemented by the European Commission.
I am saying this because, at a macro level, the main policies adopted by our country, namely the PNIESC (the Integrated National Energy and Climate Plan) and the energy strategy seem to be more in line with the ambitious targets set by the Green Deal and I think they must be revisited in order to adapt the existing policies to the context of the new European Commission. The PNIESC in particular luckily includes various aspects in line with the provided directions and I wish to congratulate the team at the Ministry of Energy for it. However, what remains to develop is the secondary legislation and the specific regulations, which seem to belong to the past.
In general terms, our country and its political and economic environment have not really opposed ambitious objectives, but they have been rather slow and unable to put them into practice.
What the authorities and the industry players need to remember is the fact that the Draghi report and, clearly, the policy of the new European Commission do not refer to a slower transition, but to harmonised measures and policies, in order to make its supporters benefit from its advantages as soon as possible. To me, this sounds like an acceleration, augmented by the increased responsibility of those who regulate or manage energy businesses.
It should be well understood the fact that the EU has already gone a long way down transition lane, it can therefore no longer stop, and that the final point is clean and affordable, not expensive energy. The translation of the advantages of green, decentralised energy production means investing in cleaner energy, flexible consumption, interconnectivity and revised market models.
Given the fact that we are still governed by a lack of planning and outdated bureaucracy in obtaining approvals, that we have a ‘’shy’’ level of interconnection and underdeveloped national infrastructure, and that we are the last Europeans to adopt smart grids in the transport and distribution infrastructure, there is a risk of being either shaken back to reality, or left behind.
I insist on the fact that we have remarkable resources for this transition and that this is an enormous opportunity for Romania, both for the local economy and for the citizens. It is essential to improve our planning processes and to promptly implement the suggested solutions. Otherwise, we risk missing an essential moment for the energy and economic future of Europe.